Top-Rated Mattress Stores in Bay Shore, New York | Open Now

Elliot Brooks
Elliot Brooks
Last Updated
Looking for the perfect mattress in Bay Shore, New York? Whether you prefer the tactile experience of browsing in person near the South Shore Mall or exploring options online from the comfort of your Suffolk County home, finding the right mattress in Bay Shore is easier than you think. This page compiles the best mattress stores serving Bay Shore, New York, helping you discover quality sleep solutions right here in Suffolk County. From Main Street to Montauk Highway, start your journey to better rest today!

Top Online Mattress Deals Available in Bay Shore, New York

Best Luxury

Saatva Classic

Hotel-quality innerspring hybrid with zoned lumbar support, white glove delivery, and three firmness levels.

From ~$1,199

★ 4.9 rating

Shop Now
Most Comfortable

WinkBed

Plush Euro-top hybrid with multiple firmness options, zoned back support, and exceptional comfort.

From ~$1,499

★ 4.8 rating

Shop Now
Best for Side Sleepers

Nolah Evolution 15

15-inch plush hybrid with zoned AirFoam® layers, great pressure relief, and cooling tech—perfect for side sleepers.

From ~$1,022

★ 4.7 rating

Shop Now

All mattresses ship directly to Bay Shore, New York with free delivery and risk-free trials.

Take Our Mattress Finder Quiz

How do you usually sleep?

Local Mattress Stores

Businesses Near Bay Shore, New York

  • 1. Mattress Firm Bayshore

    1522 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    0.4 miles away
    (631) 666-5095

  • 2. Sunrise Waterbeds

    1512 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    0.4 miles away
    (631) 665-8909

  • 3. P.C. Richard & Son

    1345 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    0.6 miles away
    (631) 969-8600

  • 4. Sleep Works

    1696 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    0.6 miles away
    (631) 647-7900

    • Why More People in Bay Shore Are Buying Mattresses Online

    • Free delivery straight to your door in Bay Shore
    • 100+ night risk-free trials — return it if you don't love it
    • Lower prices than in-store (no middlemen or overhead)
    • Plenty of top-rated options — memory foam, hybrid & more
    • No sales pressure or awkward showroom visits
    Browse Online Deals

  • 5. 1800 Easy Bed

    1696 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    0.6 miles away
    (631) 647-7900

  • 6. Rockaway Bedding

    187 Sunrise Hwy
    West Islip, NY 11795
    3.0 miles away
    (631) 321-4340

  • 7. All Custom Closet

    55 Brook Ave
    Ste B
    Deer Park, NY 11729
    3.2 miles away
    (631) 667-3333

  • 8. Bayshore Furniture & Mattress

    13 Pine Aire Dr
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
    3.3 miles away
    (631) 435-4665

  • 9. Huntleigh Healthcare Rentals

    14 Burt Dr
    Ste A
    Deer Park, NY 11729
    3.7 miles away
    (877) 586-3939

  • 10. Mattress World Plus

    770-10 Grand Blvd
    Deer Park, NY 11729
    3.9 miles away
    (631) 392-1600

What to Look For When Buying a Mattress

Choosing a mattress can feel overwhelming, but focusing on a few key features makes the decision a lot easier. Here are some of the top things to keep in mind when shopping online or in-store.

Certifications & Safety

Look for certifications like CertiPUR-US® or OEKO-TEX®, which ensure the materials are non-toxic and low in harmful chemicals.

Warranty Coverage

Most quality mattresses come with at least a 10-year warranty. Make sure it covers sagging, defects, and wear — and read the fine print.

Temperature Control

Some mattresses trap heat, especially all-foam models. Look for cooling tech like gel foam, breathable covers, or hybrid coils if you tend to sleep hot.

Motion Isolation

If you share a bed, look for mattresses that absorb movement. Memory foam and hybrid mattresses usually perform well at minimizing partner disturbance.

Edge Support

A mattress with strong edges won’t sag when you sit or sleep near the sides. This is especially important if you share your bed or like to spread out.

Local vs. Online Mattress Shopping

Local stores in your area let you test mattresses in person, talk to sales reps, and sometimes negotiate prices. But they may have limited inventory and higher overhead costs. Online brands, on the other hand, often ship directly to your door in Bay Shore, New York with free delivery, long trial periods, and lower prices thanks to fewer middlemen. Whether you value hands-on experience or convenience and savings, it’s worth weighing your options.
FeatureLocal StoresOnline Retailers
PriceOften higher due to overhead costsLower prices with frequent promotions
SelectionLimited to in-store inventoryWide range of brands and models
Trial PeriodUsually 30 days or less100–365 nights risk-free
ReturnsRestocking fees may applyHassle-free, often free returns
TestingTest in-store before buyingCan't try before purchase
DeliveryOften same-day or scheduledFree shipping to your door
WarrantyVaries by store10–25 years standard
See the Best Online Mattress Deals →

FAQs About Buying a Mattress in Bay Shore, New York

Can I test an online mattress before buying?

While you can't test before buying, risk-free trial periods let you try it at home in Bay Shore, New York — with easy returns if needed.

How thick should my mattress be?

Most people prefer a mattress that's 10-14 inches thick, but it depends on body weight and bed frame style.

Are bed-in-a-box mattresses good quality?

Yes! Many bed-in-a-box brands have top ratings and use high-quality materials — plus you get a trial period to decide.

Are there mattress recycling options in Bay Shore, New York?

Some cities may offer bulk waste pickup or recycling services. Check with the local sanitation department or mattress retailer.

Can I finance a mattress online in Bay Shore, New York?

Yes, most online brands offer financing options at checkout for residents of Bay Shore, New York, often through services like Affirm or Klarna.

Can I return a mattress if I don't like it?

Most online mattress companies offer a 100+ night trial with full refunds and free returns — no need to keep a mattress you don't love.