Mattress Shops in New Castle, Indiana - Local & Online Options

Jasmine Cole
Jasmine Cole
Last Updated
Looking for a new mattress in New Castle, Indiana? You've come to the right place! Whether you prefer to browse online or visit a local store near the Henry County seat and the historic Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame, finding the perfect mattress in New Castle, Indiana, is now easier than ever. We've compiled a directory of trusted mattress retailers serving New Castle and the surrounding areas, offering a variety of brands and sleep solutions to fit your needs. Discover the best mattress stores in New Castle, Indiana, and get ready for a good night's sleep!

Top Online Mattress Deals Available in New Castle, Indiana

Best Overall

Helix Midnight Luxe

Top-rated hybrid with balanced support, cooling features, and ideal comfort for back and side sleepers.

From ~$1,030

4.7 rating

Shop Now
Best Luxury

Saatva Classic

Hotel-quality innerspring hybrid with zoned lumbar support, white glove delivery, and three firmness levels.

From ~$1,199

4.9 rating

Shop Now
Best for Side Sleepers

Nolah Evolution 15

15-inch plush hybrid with zoned AirFoam® layers, great pressure relief, and cooling tech—perfect for side sleepers.

From ~$1,022

4.7 rating

Shop Now

All mattresses ship directly to New Castle, Indiana with free delivery and risk-free trials.

Take Our Mattress Finder Quiz

How do you usually sleep?

Local Mattress Stores

Businesses Near New Castle, Indiana
  • 1. MTB Home Furnishings

    1426 Broad St
    New Castle, IN 47362
    0.9 miles away
  • 2. New Castle Furniture Outlet

    2010 S Memorial Dr
    New Castle, IN 47362
    0.9 miles away
  • 3. American Rental Home Furnishings

    427 S Memorial Dr
    New Castle, IN 47362
    1.0 miles away
  • 4. Myers Furniture & Appliance

    2121 S Memorial Dr
    New Castle, IN 47362
    1.0 miles away
  • Why More People in New Castle Are Buying Mattresses Online

    • Free delivery straight to your door in New Castle
    • 100+ night risk-free trials — return it if you don't love it
    • Lower prices than in-store (no middlemen or overhead)
    • Plenty of top-rated options — memory foam, hybrid & more
    • No sales pressure or awkward showroom visits
  • 5. Dennis Kinser's Furniture & Appliance

    511 N Memorial Dr
    New Castle, IN 47362
    1.3 miles away
  • 6. Mattress Clearance Center of Muncie

    3837 S Madison St
    Muncie, IN 47302
    16.5 miles away
  • 7. Muncie Furniture Outlet

    1010 E 29th St
    Muncie, IN 47302
    16.7 miles away
  • 8. American Rental Home Furnishings

    1010 E 29th St
    Muncie, IN 47302
    16.7 miles away
  • 9. Mattress Firm Anderson Applewood Centre

    5409 Scatterfield Rd
    Anderson, IN 46013
    17.9 miles away
  • 10. American Mattress - Anderson

    4726 S Scatterfield Rd
    Anderson, IN 46013
    18.1 miles away

What to Look For When Buying a Mattress

Choosing a mattress can feel overwhelming, but focusing on a few key features makes the decision a lot easier. Here are some of the top things to keep in mind when shopping online or in-store.

Delivery & Setup

Many online mattresses come compressed in a box and expand at home. Some brands offer white-glove delivery and old mattress removal for a fee.

Price vs. Value

You don’t need to spend thousands for great sleep. Online brands often deliver high quality at a lower price by cutting out the retail middleman.

Firmness Level

Mattresses come in a range from soft to extra firm. Side sleepers often prefer medium-soft, while back and stomach sleepers usually need more support. Know your sleep position before you buy.

Warranty Coverage

Most quality mattresses come with at least a 10-year warranty. Make sure it covers sagging, defects, and wear — and read the fine print.

Temperature Control

Some mattresses trap heat, especially all-foam models. Look for cooling tech like gel foam, breathable covers, or hybrid coils if you tend to sleep hot.

Local vs. Online Mattress Shopping

Local stores in your area let you test mattresses in person, talk to sales reps, and sometimes negotiate prices. But they may have limited inventory and higher overhead costs. Online brands, on the other hand, often ship directly to your door in New Castle, Indiana with free delivery, long trial periods, and lower prices thanks to fewer middlemen. Whether you value hands-on experience or convenience and savings, it’s worth weighing your options.
FeatureLocal StoresOnline Retailers
PriceOften higher due to overhead costsLower prices with frequent promotions
SelectionLimited to in-store inventoryWide range of brands and models
Trial PeriodUsually 30 days or less100–365 nights risk-free
ReturnsRestocking fees may applyHassle-free, often free returns
TestingTest in-store before buyingCan't try before purchase
DeliveryOften same-day or scheduledFree shipping to your door
WarrantyVaries by store10–25 years standard

FAQs About Buying a Mattress in New Castle, Indiana

What firmness level is best for side sleepers?

Medium to medium-soft mattresses are usually ideal for side sleepers, offering better pressure relief at the shoulders and hips.

What's the difference between memory foam and hybrid mattresses?

Memory foam contours to your body, while hybrids combine foam with springs for more bounce and airflow.

Do online mattresses come with a warranty?

Most reputable brands offer warranties from 10 to 25 years, covering defects and sagging beyond a certain depth.

Can I test an online mattress before buying?

While you can't test before buying, risk-free trial periods let you try it at home in New Castle, Indiana — with easy returns if needed.

When is the best time to buy a mattress in New Castle, Indiana?

Holiday weekends like Memorial Day and Black Friday are great times to buy a mattress. Many online brands also run year-round discounts.

Can I finance a mattress online in New Castle, Indiana?

Yes, most online brands offer financing options at checkout for residents of New Castle, Indiana, often through services like Affirm or Klarna.